Skip to content

Compare

Stripe Smart Disputes vs DisputeGuard: do you need both?

Smart Disputes answers Stripe disputes for 30% of every win, using data Stripe already holds. Here is what it covers, what it cannot see in a WooCommerce store, and when a flat monthly plan fits better.

Smart Disputes reads Stripe’s data. Your store holds the rest.

If most of your disputes are card fraud and Stripe already has the proof, Smart Disputes may be enough, and it adds no fee of its own until you win. If you ship physical goods, run subscriptions or sell services from a WooCommerce or custom store, or you also take PayPal, the proof lives in your store, and you need something that can read it. You can run both, as long as only one of them submits each dispute.

What “Stripe chargeback protection” means today

The phrase points at two Stripe products. Only one is current.

  • Current

    Smart Disputes

    Stripe’s AI rules engine builds an evidence packet from Stripe’s own data, your transaction data and cardholder data. Eligibility depends on reason code, payment method and the evidence available. Stripe bills 30% of the disputed amount on each dispute you win, and no Smart Disputes fee on a loss. It does not guarantee a win.

  • Launched 2019

    Chargeback Protection

    Stripe announced it in 2019 for fraud disputes: a fee of 0.4% per transaction, with covered fraud disputes reimbursed. We could not find it listed on Stripe’s pricing page today, so ask Stripe before you plan around it.

Radar is a separate product that screens payments to prevent fraud before it happens. Stripe lists it from $10 a month, or pay as you go from $0.05 per screened transaction.

Smart Disputes and DisputeGuard side by side

Same disputes, different data and different billing.

Stripe Smart Disputes compared with DisputeGuard, by feature
FeatureStripe Smart DisputesDisputeGuard
Price model30% of the disputed amount on each dispute you win, plus Stripe’s dispute fees.A flat monthly plan, no success fee and no percentage of recovered revenue. Stripe’s dispute fees still apply.
Evidence it usesStripe’s internal data, your transaction data and cardholder data, as Stripe holds it when the packet is generated.Orders and activity synced from your store or app: shipments, logins, downloads, messages, refunds, cancellations, policies. Plus Stripe data.
Dispute reasonsStripe decides which disputes are eligible, by reason code, payment method and evidence.A playbook per dispute reason writes the rebuttal and scores the evidence. Visa CE 3.0 prior transactions are included when they exist.
Deadline and submissionWith no action from you, Stripe submits just before the dispute times out. Auto-submit can be turned off in Dashboard settings.Disputes import the moment they open, deadline shown up front. You submit, or auto-submit sends once the packet is strong or the deadline nears.
Merchant controlYou can switch auto-submit off and answer the dispute yourself.You review the packet and its strength score before it goes. Auto-submit is off by default.
WooCommerce dataNot a listed source. Order notes, carrier tracking and support messages stay outside the data Stripe describes.The WooCommerce plugin syncs orders and activity and answers evidence requests. The Connect API covers other stores.
PayPalStripe disputes only.PayPal disputes are supported in beta.

What a $100 dispute costs in Stripe fees

US standard pricing, which may differ by country. Stripe charges $15 when a dispute is received and $15 more when you counter it yourself, returned if you win. Fees only.

  • Smart Disputes

    You win

    $45

    $15 received fee + $30 (30% of $100)

  • Smart Disputes

    You lose

    $15

    $15 received fee, no Smart Disputes fee

  • You counter it

    You win

    $15

    $15 received fee, $15 counter fee returned

  • You counter it

    You lose

    $30

    $15 received fee + $15 counter fee

With DisputeGuard

You counter through Stripe, so the counter-it-yourself fees apply. DisputeGuard adds a flat monthly plan and no cut of a win. Smart Disputes’ share grows with the order: 30% of $1,000 is $300.

Other recovery tools

Chargeflow Automation charges 25% of each recovered chargeback, listed apart from the dispute fee.

Run your own numbers in the chargeback cost calculator.

Where Smart Disputes stops short for store owners

It works from data Stripe holds, which suits a stolen card with a matching IP and a 3D Secure result. It fits less well when the proof sits in your store.

Disputes decided by store-side proof

Product not received
Carrier scans and delivery proof beyond basic tracking.
Product not as described
The listing, order notes and what the customer was told.
Subscription cancelled
Cancellation requests, billing and account activity.
Credit not processed
Refund records and the messages around them.
Services not provided
Logins, usage and proof of delivery of the service.

Limits of any Stripe evidence response

  • One response per dispute. Submission is final, so a packet cannot be topped up.
  • Evidence files are capped at 4.5 MB combined.
  • Smart Disputes builds its packet after the dispute is filed, from what Stripe holds then.
  • Charges on other processors are not covered.

The first two come from Stripe’s dispute rules, so they bind any tool that submits through Stripe, DisputeGuard included. What differs is what goes into the one response.

What DisputeGuard adds from your store

It collects store-side proof ahead of time and builds the response around the dispute reason.

DisputeGuard is not launched yet and runs in test mode, so there are no merchant results or win rates to quote. The 14-day Growth trial starts when you connect your first store or processor, with no card. See pricing, or how it connects to WooCommerce and Stripe.

  • Watches Stripe, with PayPal in beta. Disputes import the moment they open, with the deadline shown up front.
  • A WooCommerce plugin first. The Connect API, with PHP and Node SDKs, covers other stores and apps.
  • A playbook for each dispute reason writes the rebuttal and scores how strong the evidence is.
  • Receipts attach, and Visa Compelling Evidence 3.0 prior-transaction history is included when the same customer, device or IP has undisputed purchases.
  • Each packet includes a receipt and an evidence summary PDF.
  • You review and submit, or turn on auto-submit, which sends once the packet is strong enough or before the deadline.

Who should use which

The deciding question is where the proof for your disputes lives.

Smart Disputes may be enough

  • Most of your disputes are card fraud.
  • Stripe already holds the proof: AVS and CVC checks, 3D Secure, IP address and device.
  • You want no Smart Disputes fee unless you win.

Store-side proof matters

  • You sell physical goods on WooCommerce and delivery is disputed.
  • You run subscriptions or sell services, where logins, usage and cancellations decide the case.
  • You also take PayPal and want one place for both processors.

Smart Disputes and DisputeGuard, answered.

Sources, checked November 2026

Does Stripe have chargeback protection?

Stripe has Smart Disputes today, which builds evidence for eligible disputes and bills 30% of each dispute you win. Stripe also launched a Chargeback Protection product in 2019, at 0.4% per transaction for fraud disputes, but we could not find it listed on Stripe’s pricing page now. Radar, priced separately, is Stripe’s fraud prevention tool.

Is Smart Disputes free?

No. Stripe takes 30% of the disputed amount on each dispute you win, and no Smart Disputes fee on a loss. Stripe’s $15 dispute received fee applies either way, at US standard pricing.

Can I use Smart Disputes and DisputeGuard together?

Yes, as long as only one of them submits each dispute, because Stripe accepts one response. For disputes you answer in DisputeGuard, turn off Smart Disputes auto-submit in the dispute settings of your Stripe Dashboard, so Stripe does not send its own packet before you have reviewed yours.

Does Stripe Smart Disputes use my WooCommerce order data?

Only what reaches Stripe. Stripe’s documentation lists its internal data, your transaction data and cardholder data. Order details your store passes to Stripe with the payment count as transaction data. Order notes, carrier tracking and customer messages that stay in your store are not described as a source.

Is DisputeGuard live?

No. DisputeGuard is not launched yet and runs in test mode, with no merchants, so there are no results or win rates to quote. You can start the 14-day Growth trial, with no card, and see how it builds evidence packets.

Try it in test mode.

Connect Stripe and your store and the 14-day Growth trial starts, with no card.